Singers Avi Kaplan, Kevin Olusola, Kirstie Maldonado, Mitch Grassi and Scott Hoying of Pentatonix perform in concert in Amsterdam on April 28. Robin Utrecht / Abaca Press / TNS

Pentatonix continues to redefine a cappella music

Here are two of the most common reasons music listeners either refuse to listen to a cappella music or are quickly bored by it: 1) It’s almost always covers of popular songs, and 2) It’s difficult to keep arrangements of songs as interesting as music with actual instruments. In its self-titled fourth album, Pentatonix, a five-person a cappella group and the 2011 winner of NBC’s “The Sing-Off” (2009 – present), remedies both of these issues.

Members Scott Hoying, Kirstin Maldonado and Mitch Grassi started off as high school friends who liked to sing. They wanted to audition for “The Sing-Off,” but the show requires auditioning groups to have at least four members. The trio soon discovered bassist Avi Kaplan and beatboxer and cellist Kevin Olusola. The group, which met for the first time just the day before auditions for “The Sing-Off,” went on to win the competition and is now arguably the biggest name in a cappella.

Pentatonix made history this month when its newest release became the first a cappella album to hit the number one spot on the Billboard 200 chart. Released Oct. 16, “Pentatonix” features mostly original songs, though the deluxe version includes several covers. 

“Pentatonix” opens with three of the album’s best songs. “Na Na Na,” the first track, begins with Grassi’s smooth vocals accompanied by clapping in the background. There is no way to avoid dancing to this song; it’s catchy and upbeat, and the background harmonies and runs are tight.

“Can’t Sleep Love,” a fan favorite since its release as a single in September, has a funky R&B vibe that is anchored by Kaplan’s groovy bass line. One of the biggest challenges of transitioning to all-original music is creating original lyrics. With lines like “Somebody wake up my heart / Light me up / Set fire to my soul,” “Can’t Sleep Love” makes clear that Pentatonix doesn’t have too much of a problem with this switch.

With an infectious chorus and even a rap from Olusola, “Sing” is another dance-worthy number, which is made evident in its official music videoEach member of the group has a chance to shine on the song, which can’t be said for some of the remaining tracks on the album.

The album only continues to impress with “Ref,” which peaks during its catchy chorus. Maldonado gets her own solo in the second verse, reminding listeners that though Hoying’s voice is undoubtedly incredible, the entire group is talented. One of the downfalls of the album is how heavily it focuses on Hoying. He is lead vocalist on 10 of the 13 songs, while Grassi leads on four, Maldonado two and Kaplan and Olusola on one apiece. This lineup clearly disproportionately favors the main vocal trio (Hoying, Grassi, Maldonaldo) which will delight Hoying’s fans but will disappoint those who want to see the range that Pentatonix has to offer.

There are a few songs on the album that aren’t so memorable — two of these are Kaplan (“Light in the Hallway”) and Maldonado’s (“Water”) only solo songs, which is unfortunate. Both songs are pretty, but don’t stand out as among the greatest on the album. The same can be said for “Rose Gold,” which has some disjointed, minimalist rhythms that don’t quite work anywhere except the chorus. “Take Me Home,” a softer song, is, however, probably the best slower song on the album; it is focused on pure vocals, which is a nice change of pace.

The only cover on the standard version is “If I Ever Fall in Love,” a cover of Shai’s version from 1992, featuring Jason Derulo. If anyone had any doubt that Derulo, the same singer most people associate with “Talk Dirty” (2014) and “Wiggle” (2014) can sing, those doubts will surely be erased after listening to this cover. From the start of this track, listeners know it will be great; Derulo’s and Hoying’s velvety tones are enough to make anyone a little weak in the knees. Derulo hits high notes with surprising ease and, during the breakdown, belts an incredible sounding G#5. Be on the lookout for collaborations in the future, because Derulo and Pentatonix are a golden combination.

This album has put Pentatonix on the map and will no doubt entice fans of all musical genres. It could even appeal to those who swore that they were sick and tired of all the a cappella.


2 Responses

Leave a Reply
  1. Susan Rastella
    Oct 28, 2015 - 03:33 AM

    A fair and informative review of the Pentatonix album. I too feel they leads were a little heavy on the Hoying side. Although he has great range and control, we don’t get to hear the other great voices that each member has. Most of the tracks are very well suited for radio which I am sure was one of the big goals of this album. Pentatonix, however, is known for taking risks and during things in an unusual way. There was no disappoint with the album when it comes to that.

    The review was a little harsh on the “Water” track because if you listen closely you hear some of the new vocal acrobatics that Kirstin Maldonado has incorporated in to the song. The song “Cracked” will probably be a Pentaholic favorite. A small glimpse of the song was on the documentary “On My Way Home” and fans were anxious to hear the rest of it. It’s a good jump around and nod your head kind of song that’s just fun. There was also one other risky track,

    “Light in the Hallway”, was intentionally written as a lullaby. Most bands, a cappella or otherwise, wouldn’t dare try that; but PTX did anyway. Why not; PTX Volume III had a track sung entirely in French. That’s one of the many things that makes Pentatonix so great. Overall I’d give a 4 1/2 star rating for this HISTORY MAKING ALBUM.

  2. Solenn Breizh
    Oct 28, 2015 - 04:06 AM

    I don’t agree. Yes Scott has a lot of leads, so what? His voice is so versatile! They all have a role to play in the Group, and THEY CHOOSE TOGETHER! Same about Water and Light In The Hallway: you know what? PTX are 5 artists with very different musical tastes, and the album shows this. Of course it’s pretty unusual for a band to be so diverse, but the Fans LOVE IT. This said, the rest of the article is great.

Related News